Defeat Into Victory
Memoir Intermediate Primary Sources
🇬🇧 British
The commander of the Fourteenth Army tells how a beaten force was rebuilt to destroy the Japanese in Burma.
The Verdict
Widely regarded as the finest memoir any general produced in the war. Field Marshal Slim took a beaten, demoralized army in Burma and rebuilt it into the force that destroyed the Japanese at Imphal and Kohima — and his account of how he did it is honest about failure, generous to his soldiers, and free of the self-justification that mars most commanders' memoirs. Still taught at staff colleges, it is a masterclass in leadership as much as a history of a campaign.
Who Should Read It
Read it if you want
- The best general's memoir of the war
- Readers interested in leadership and morale
- The strategic story of the Burma campaign
- Anyone who values candor from the top
Look elsewhere if you want
- The ground-level soldier's experience (see Fraser)
- A short read — it is detailed
- The European or Pacific theaters
Why We Rated It 4.8
Historical Context
Slim commanded the Fourteenth Army — the 'Forgotten Army' — in the Burma campaign, turning the 1942 retreat into the victories of 1944–45 at Imphal, Kohima, and the Irrawaddy crossings. The memoir was first published in 1956.
Events Covered
Editions & Reading Notes
Cooper Square / Pan paperbackThe standard reading edition.
Read It Alongside
Quartered Safe Out Here George MacDonald Fraser · 1992 · ★ 4.8
Memoir 
The Forgotten Highlander Alistair Urquhart · 2010 · ★ 4.5
Memoir Where to Buy
ISBN: 978-0815410225
Read This Against
The same events seen from a different vantage point. The fullest understanding often lives in the space between accounts that don't agree.
Ship of Ghosts James Hornfischer · 2006 · American
Popular History Other Books About the Same Events
Quartered Safe Out Here George MacDonald Fraser · 1992
Memoir 
The Bridge on the River Kwai Pierre Boulle · 1952
Historical Fiction Ship of Ghosts James Hornfischer · 2006
Popular History 
King Rat James Clavell · 1962
Historical Fiction The Forgotten Highlander Alistair Urquhart · 2010
Memoir More by Field Marshal William Slim
Guadalcanal Diary 1943 · 263 pages
Flyboys 2003 · 398 pages
Ghost Soldiers 2001 · 342 pages
The Forgotten Soldier 1965 · 465 pages
A Woman in Berlin 1959 · 261 pages
Catch-22 1961 · 453 pages
Slaughterhouse-Five 1969 · 275 pages
The Naked and the Dead 1948 · 721 pages
Flags of Our Fathers 2000 · 376 pages
In Harm's Way 2001 · 339 pages
D-Day Through German Eyes 2015 · 218 pages
Is Paris Burning? 1965 · 378 pages
All the Light We Cannot See 2014 · 531 pages
Shattered Sword 2005 · 613 pages
At Dawn We Slept 1981 · 873 pages
The Splendid and the Vile 2020 · 585 pages
First Light 2002 · 338 pages
Das Boot 1973 · 560 pages
The Cruel Sea 1951 · 416 pages
Quartered Safe Out Here 1992 · 225 pages
The Bridge on the River Kwai 1952 · 224 pages
Ivan's War 2006 · 462 pages
Bloodlands 2010 · 524 pages
Ordinary Men 1992 · 271 pages
The Tattooist of Auschwitz 2018 · 288 pages
Schindler's List 1982 · 400 pages
The Book Thief 2005 · 552 pages
The Hiding Place 1971 · 241 pages
Masters of the Air 2006 · 671 pages
A Higher Call 2012 · 392 pages
The Nightingale 2015 · 440 pages
The Second World War 1948 · 4448 pages
The Storm of War 2009 · 712 pages
Why the Allies Won 1995 · 396 pages
A World at Arms 1994 · 1178 pages
The Wages of Destruction 2006 · 800 pages
The Third Reich at War 2008 · 926 pages
Hitler 2008 · 1072 pages
Inside the Third Reich 1969 · 596 pages
The Last Days of Hitler 1947 · 288 pages
Savage Continent 2012 · 480 pages
Crusade in Europe 1948 · 559 pages
Eichmann in Jerusalem 1963 · 312 pages
Sophie's Choice 1979 · 562 pages
Mila 18 1961 · 539 pages
The Zookeeper's Wife 2007 · 368 pages
The Boy in the Striped Pajamas 2006 · 216 pages
Sarah's Key 2007 · 294 pages
Number the Stars 1989 · 137 pages
We Were the Lucky Ones 2017 · 416 pages
The Choice 2017 · 320 pages
The Reader 1995 · 218 pages
The 900 Days 1969 · 635 pages
City of Thieves 2008 · 258 pages
The Unwomanly Face of War 1985 · 384 pages
Russia at War, 1941-1945 1964 · 1136 pages
When Titans Clashed 1995 · 414 pages
The Battle of Kursk 1999 · 472 pages
Panzer Leader 1952 · 554 pages
The Rape of Nanking 1997 · 290 pages
Forgotten Ally 2013 · 458 pages
Empire of the Sun 1984 · 351 pages
Eagle Against the Sun 1985 · 589 pages
The Pacific 2010 · 449 pages
Tales of the South Pacific 1947 · 384 pages
Thirty Seconds Over Tokyo 1943 · 221 pages
The Making of the Atomic Bomb 1986 · 886 pages
Embracing Defeat 1999 · 676 pages
The Girls of Atomic City 2013 · 373 pages
Beyond Band of Brothers 2006 · 292 pages
If You Survive 1987 · 288 pages
Company Commander 1947 · 278 pages
A Time for Trumpets 1985 · 712 pages
D-Day Girls 2019 · 384 pages
A Woman of No Importance 2019 · 368 pages
Citizens of London 2010 · 471 pages
Naples '44 1978 · 206 pages
Beneath a Scarlet Sky 2017 · 524 pages
Alan Turing: The Enigma 1983 · 736 pages
Code Girls 2017 · 416 pages
Atonement 2001 · 351 pages
The English Patient 1992 · 305 pages
The Young Lions 1948 · 689 pages
No Ordinary Time 1994 · 759 pages
King Rat 1962 · 479 pages
Tears in the Darkness 2009 · 463 pages
We Band of Angels 1999 · 327 pages
The Forgotten Highlander 2010 · 320 pages
Life After Life 2013 · 529 pages
The Good Shepherd 1955 · 256 pages
Iron Coffins 1969 · 329 pages
When Books Went to War 2014 · 267 pages
Blood Red Snow 2002 · 320 pages
Cross of Iron 1956 · 444 pages
Soldat 1992 · 384 pages
Symphony for the City of the Dead 2015 · 456 pages
The Siege 2001 · 294 pages
The Bronze Horseman 2000 · 637 pages
The Kindly Ones 2006 · 992 pages
The Librarian of Auschwitz 2017 · 423 pages
Lilac Girls 2016 · 487 pages
HHhH 2010 · 327 pages
Into That Darkness 1974 · 380 pages
KL: A History of the Nazi Concentration Camps 2015 · 865 pages
The Volunteer 2019 · 505 pages
When Hitler Stole Pink Rabbit 1971 · 191 pages
The Book of Lost Names 2020 · 388 pages
Hiroshima Diary 1955 · 238 pages
Requiem for Battleship Yamato 1952 · 152 pages
Midway: The Battle That Doomed Japan 1955 · 266 pages
Lost in Shangri-La 2011 · 384 pages
The Rommel Papers 1953 · 545 pages
Between Silk and Cyanide 1998 · 614 pages
Monte Cassino 2003 · 416 pages
Captain Corelli's Mandolin 1994 · 437 pages
War As I Knew It 1947 · 425 pages
Up Front 1945 · 228 pages
The War That Saved My Life 2015 · 316 pages
Goodnight Mister Tom 1981 · 318 pages
Code Name Verity 2012 · 339 pages
Salt to the Sea 2016 · 391 pages
Frequently Asked Questions
- Why is Defeat Into Victory so highly regarded?
- It combines authoritative military history with unusual honesty about mistakes and a deep respect for ordinary soldiers, and is still studied as a model of command.
- What should I read alongside it?
- George MacDonald Fraser's Quartered Safe Out Here gives the private soldier's view of the same campaign.