The Kindly Ones
An SS intelligence officer narrates his own war — Babi Yar, Stalingrad, Auschwitz — with monstrous erudition and no remorse.
The Verdict
Few novels have divided serious readers as sharply as this one. Jonathan Littell hands the narration to Maximilien Aue, a cultured, monstrous SS intelligence officer who carries the reader through Babi Yar, Stalingrad, and Auschwitz with erudition, self-justification, and not a flicker of remorse. It is a vast, deliberately punishing attempt to inhabit the perpetrator's mind — praised by some as the most ambitious Holocaust novel of the century and condemned by others as gratuitous. Extraordinary and repellent in the same breath, it is not a book one recommends lightly.
Who Should Read It
Read it if you want
- The Holocaust from inside the perpetrator
- An ambitious, punishing literary undertaking
- The Prix Goncourt's most controversial winner
- Extremity faced without flinching
Look elsewhere if you want
- A first book on the Holocaust
- Anything restrained or consoling
- Restraint over graphic extremity
Why We Rated It 4.0
Historical Context
The Kindly Ones (2006, Les Bienveillantes) is narrated by a fictional SS officer moving through the major atrocities of the Eastern war and the Holocaust. It won France's Prix Goncourt and was both acclaimed as a landmark and attacked as excessive.
Criticisms & Debates
Reception split violently: admirers call it the most ambitious perpetrator's-eye novel of the Holocaust, while critics find its length, graphic content, and narrator's perversions gratuitous and morally dubious. There is no consensus, which is itself part of the book's notoriety.
Events Covered
Read It Alongside
Where to Buy
ISBN: 978-0061353468
Read This Against
The same events seen from a different vantage point. The fullest understanding often lives in the space between accounts that don't agree.
Other Books About the Same Events
Frequently Asked Questions
- Why is The Kindly Ones so controversial?
- It narrates the Holocaust from the unrepentant perspective of an SS perpetrator, in graphic detail — hailed by some as a masterpiece and condemned by others as gratuitous.
- Is it a good introduction to the subject?
- No — it is long, extreme, and demanding; it assumes considerable prior grounding and a strong stomach.